Walking in Skeptical
I may have been less cynical about the gym memberships I’ve bought during New Year’s sales and my chances in the first poker tournament I ever entered than I was walking into my hypnotherapist’s office for the first time.
This was even after two online sessions, before we did any hypnosis, where I shared about myself in great detail. After three years of talk therapy, I was preeeeeeetty good at this. I could describe my issues, triggers and their origins forwards, backwards, upside down, from a bird’s eye view, through drawing – just about any which way (except for charades/role playing, never ever ask me to do that!!)
I had my story down with its footnotes,
supporting evidence and theses in constant revision.
I really liked the hypnotherapist, Tina, immediately. Her warmth came through the screen, and she asked the best-timed questions with quiet precision. I felt very seen and heard. So when it came time to meet in her clinical space in person for the first time, you would think I would be skipping down the hallway, fully confident and ready to go.
No.
I was still very, very, very skeptical when I went in.
Would this work? Could I even be hypnotized? What was I even doing?
If you read my last post, you already know I walked in holding two opposite things at once: no real idea why I’d reached out, and total commitment to being there anyway. My old friend, paradox.
In person, she was just as warm, with a quiet, self-assured confidence. We chatted a bit, and then she asked what I wanted to work on.
I decided to start small, a little trial run, as it were. I was like… “Okay, let’s try something that has bugged me for a long time, that is a weird block, but not something really ‘deep’.”
Like, let’s hop into the kiddie pool side of my subconscious and see what, if anything, happens.
The French Thing
The thing I chose had been sitting there for years: my complicated relationship with speaking French.
I grew up in British Columbia and went into late French immersion starting in grade 7. When I went to high school, I had “Mr. A” for French and a few other courses he taught in French, for the next four years.
He did not like me.
I had never experienced anything like that before in school. I had been one of those kids who was more like a teacher’s pet without the sucking-up part. This was horrific and confusing.
Looking back, I understand that whatever was happening with him had nothing to do with me. As a young teenager, of course, that distinction didn’t help much.
Whenever I would speak, he would look at me like I was stupid and act like he had absolutely no clue what I was saying. It became so bad that I would write things out in advance, rehearse them, and check in with my friends in class – “Do you understand what I am saying?”
And they were like “Uhhh yeah.”
Even though my friends saw what was happening and validated my reality, it did not change my emotional reaction as a teenager with very little power in that classroom. I eventually just stopped talking – refusing to speak in French. I began to hate the language, and those courses were my worst grades.
Automatic Mute Button
Fast-forward over a bunch of years, and I was living in Montreal. Moving through the city, I would understand what people were saying, but the MOMENT it came to speak and someone had even a flicker on their face, like they needed to listen a little closer to understand me, I would just stop talking.
Stop talking.
I would just stop. Mouth open or closed, it didn’t matter. I would just look at them – the poor person – confused by this suddenly mute woman standing there looking at them.
Coffee and pastry? “Oh, you weren’t sure if you heard chocolatine or amandine over the noise in the shop and through my West Coast Canadian accent?”
Mute.
Help at the STM counter with my metro card? “I understand you and your questions, and my brain knows exactly how to answer you in French – BUT you kind of looked at me weird, and there is that glass that makes things hard to hear.”
Mute.
You get the picture. I understood, for the most part, what people were asking and saying in one-to-one conversations, AND I knew, for the most part, how to reply…
And yet… I often couldn’t.
I froze. Silent.
I even took a few French classes when I arrived in Montreal. The teachers were incredibly nice, and I still avoided speaking even though the whole raison d’être of taking the classes was to get over my issue.
My DIY Exposure Therapy plan of going back to French school was not working.
This was going to be a real problem.
Was it my most pressing or deeply painful issue? Absolutely not. I had a job where I spoke in English. In practical terms, it was mostly an annoyance – but also something I felt deep shame about because my extreme reactions just did not make sense.
Being aware of the issue was not changing it.
I could understand what people were saying. My brain knew how to respond. Yet I couldn’t do it simply by telling myself it was safe – even in spaces that were genuinely safe and easy.
Spaces without a “Mr. A” and his mocking face.
Jumping In
So in that therapy room I said, with ALL the confidence
of someone who has anxiety over ordering un café allongé,
“Let’s work on the French thing.”
What she actually had me do was nothing like what I’d imagined hypnosis would be.
I settled into the reclining chair, closed my eyes, took a few deep breaths, and listened to her voice as she helped me relax, and followed her direction.
She had me bring up a vivid memory of my high school French teacher with his awful face, those eyes, that smirk, the tone of his voice – FEELING everything that came with being back in that space.
I imagined stepping back and watching myself watch the same scene on a screen, then running it forwards and backwards, fast-forwarding and rewinding it like an old VHS tape, over and over until…
…until, I don’t know, the intense feeling of looking at his face felt like…
nothing?
No sinking feeling in my gut. No tightness in my chest. No block in my throat.
Processing…
It was NOT at all what I was expecting from a session of hypnotherapy. It felt more mundane and more like “work” on my part than I’d anticipated.
My conscious mind, which I had apparently expected to be silent, even wandered back in occasionally to offer commentary:
“Oh my god, this back-and-forth is getting boring…
Is this really hypnotherapy? How is this going to…?”
My conscious mind was offering commentary about as helpful as those old men in the balcony of The Muppet Show. Which, naturally, also had me wondering whether I was even hypnotized if these thoughts kept popping in. Was this working?
When I “came back to the room,” I felt really relaxed, but still a little bit not all there. Putting my feet on the ground helped. We chatted a bit, and then I went home.
I did not feel like I had transformed anything.
I still felt very much like me.
My skeptical conscious mind went back to work, maybe because I had set it aside for a bit and it wanted to reassert itself.
“You do not feel like a different person. This hypnosis stuff?
We were right to question it.”
What Just Happened?
And then, a few days later, I was picking up my son from daycare.
The two women who cared for him were the loveliest, warmest people imaginable, and they spoke very little English.
I started to speak to them in French.
I made mistakes.
They didn’t understand something I said, and I didn’t stop talking. I just repeated myself.
I had been bracing myself, like I always had, waiting for those feelings to come up and smack me around. I was ready to fight through them.
And… they weren’t there.
It was almost like watching a car wreck happen in slow motion… I was in shock and could not believe this was actually happening.
I was at ease.
Now, I did not transform into someone who suddenly loved speaking French. I still had my accent. I still made mistakes. But what had felt like a 15 on a scale of 1 to 10 was suddenly maybe a 4 or 5.
I could speak.
I could be misunderstood.
I could repeat myself.
And my body did not believe it was being attacked.
My normally loquacious, erudite inner critic, never short of a scathing monologue and an opinion on absolutely everything, was rendered speechless. Well, almost.
“Huh, well, you don’t say…”
I was still in shock.
What was this magic?
HOW DOES EVERYONE IN THE WORLD
NOT KNOW ABOUT THIS?
I had spent decades with this block. I knew where it came from. I knew what it felt like in my body. I could tell myself I was safe and it didn’t change a thing. Exposing myself to more and more French-speaking opportunities to “unlearn it” was not working.
Nothing had shifted it since high school. And then this one session – one I was skeptical going into, skeptical during, and skeptical after – changed a reaction I had never been able to reason my way out of.
It isn’t always this fast or this dramatic for everyone, but for me, with this, it was.
The next session, I was like, “Okay, I got my feet wet. Now I am serious – let’s jump into the deeper part of the pool…”

